Initially posted on Might 7, 2016 @ 5:29 PM
Confirmity in Conformity
Security is the business of conformity. That is even though most of the issues folks imagine they have to conform with are legendary.
Within the very transient historical past of security we now have the scenario the place the dominant Security worldview is mechanistic, targeted on – security as hurt from objects and danger aversion. That is greatest captured within the perception that security is all about ‘damaging energies’. Someway an object has an power of its personal, simply ready for a human to launch it? The main target stays on the potential of the thing not the social preparations of people. One of the simplest ways to cope with dropped objects is to have a dropped objects calculator???
The winter in Canberra this 12 months is operating late, usually by late April the nights get right down to 1 or 2 Celsius and the times wrestle to get above 15. One of many winter duties is to cut beginning wooden for the hearth, clear out the fireside and chimney and set up the whole lot prepared for the bitter chilly. Splitting wooden with an axe, blockbuster and tomahawk is dangerous. The implement must be sharpened after which its use requires accuracy and talent, one thing that diminishes with older age. Sadly, carrying gloves with chopping takes away the sensitivity for ‘feeling’ what one is doing, it really makes it much less protected. Possibly that’s why skilled woodchoppers don’t put on steelcap boots and gloves? (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uwcFng9wfDs; https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TZ5v6OZgCbU) So, this 12 months I almost had the whole lot carried out after I nicked my finger with the tomahawk, oh my goodness I obtained a reduce. I have to be silly. All accidents are preventable. I need to discover a trigger, as a result of a trigger means one thing or somebody in charge and blame is the title of the security recreation. I do know, the issue was the tomahawk design, the temperature of the deal with, the form of the blade, the ‘power’ of the implement, the time of the day, the placement, my approach in chopping, not carrying gloves, the way in which I held the wooden. Possibly I ought to have sat down for 4 hours and contemplated all the explanations for blame and punish myself? So, I recorded the damage and wrote out a report and can see if I can scale back finger cuts over the following 5 years and see if that frequency charge will make a safer chopping course of. I’ll document that finger reduce together with my spouse’s finger reduce in cooking preparation two months in the past, and my finger reduce in pruning the grape vine in our family danger register, that can make all of it higher. I obtained a band-aid and completed off the job.
Right here’s a quote from the most recent e-book due out in July, Greg Smith feedback:
‘GREG: And it appears to me to be such an issue we have now in, in security that we’re so targeted on minor, trivial issues from a authorized perspective, they don’t create authorized legal responsibility, somebody cuts their finger, doesn’t create authorized legal responsibility. The courts settle for that this simply occurs within the regular course of a life. You’re not going to be prosecuted; you’re not going to be sued, as a result of somebody’s cuts their finger. You blow up an oil rig and also you pollute the place with oil and also you destroy peoples livelihoods and kill tens of individuals in your small business, sure the courts are going to take a special perspective on that.
And I simply discover it fairly extraordinary; and never simply from a authorized perspective, my concern from a security perspective, and I see this on a regular basis – I’d be thinking about your views on this Rob … is that the workforce, and never even the workforce, members of the general public who I’ve to talk to socially, suppose that security is an utter nonsense due to our deal with the trivial.
ROB: I really like ALARP as a result of it endorses for me the human and subjective aspect of managing danger. I see in business, this fixed have to mechanise, management, shut down and objectify danger. I come into organisations, and I used to be in a single not way back, the place they’d fifty thousand objects registered on their hazard register they usually confirmed this to me proudly and right here was their proof that they we’re managing danger. Bang, take a look at this. I used to be simply flabbergasted, it’s not goal and also you’re making an attempt to concretise, metricise one thing which the Act and the Regulation doesn’t.’
It’s identical to Due Diligence, it’s subjective. Now if you may get over that, you received’t begin setting foolish objectives, like ‘all accidents are preventable’, and ‘zero’, and all form of foolish language, that goes with it. You’ll realise that danger is managed inside a context, by human beings, who do one of the best they will.
Sadly, this isn’t how Security works. Affirmation bias is alive and properly in security (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Confirmation_bias). What affirmation bias does is assist solidify ‘myths as reality’ in security. No matter what the courts say and the Regulation says, security will need to have zero when ALARP is a denial of zero. The extra folks conform to the parable, the extra an object-centred strategy to danger is confirmed. see Snap, Crackle, Pop. That’s the Sound we Like to Hear
Like I say within the e-book:
‘ROB: The courtroom then tells you that quantity (LTI, FRMTI) is completely meaningless however business continues to culturally attribute worth to it. And so it’unhappy and a bit like a ‘cargo cult’. The coke bottle falls out of the sky and it’s a god, it’s precisely the identical. You understand, right here we’ve obtained these matrices, or these numbers, or these pyramids and curves, we attribute worth to them, the courtroom tells us they’re of no worth and we nonetheless grasp onto the coke bottle and worship the rattling factor’.
Any examination of the WHS curriculum additional reveals simply how this cargo cult is maintained. The curriculum is based on a deal with object not topics. The protection curriculum is all about methods, mechanics, engineering, legalism and objects and so little is dedicated to folks, communication, listening, conversations and all that’s human about danger. The WHS curriculum simply confirms the mechanistic worldview and so makes it straightforward to adapt to the brand new regular. Affirmation in conformation.
Newest posts by Dr Rob Lengthy (see all)
PhD., MEd., MOH., BEd., BTh., Dip T., Dip Min., Cert IV TAA, MRMIA
Rob is the founding father of Human Dymensions and has in depth expertise, {qualifications} and experience throughout a spread of sectors together with authorities, training, company, business and group sectors over 30 years. Rob has labored in any respect ranges of the training and coaching sector together with serving on varied publish graduate government, publish graduate supervision, publish graduate course design and implementation applications.
